ReportsGreen GuidesSource Library
Browse all reports

Phase 1C Engineering Content

For the January 2026 rule, also evaluate the public-transportation provisions in §5.3(f)–(j). A qualifying §5.3(g)3 case can use Table 5-3 after the prescribed investigation without requesting a waiver. The ordinary chapter waiver/variance descriptions below do not remove that rule-specific pathway. N.J.A.C. 7:8-5.3, pp. 35–37.

This report compares the stored July-era and January 2026 collections. Use each PDF's printed revision date: some chapters were retained unchanged. Project applicability, including the later September 2026 amendment, is explained in the rules comparison.

NJ Stormwater BMP Manual - Chapters 4, 5, and 6

Pollutant Removal - SWM Standards and Computations - Groundwater Recharge

2023 vs. 2026 Edition Comparison Source-corrected April 9, 2026 - OPAL Stormwater Engineering Knowledge System

Source Documents: - 2023: BMP Chapter 4, BMP Chapter 5, BMP Chapter 6 - 2026: BMP Chapter 4, BMP Chapter 5, BMP Chapter 6


Section 1 - Stormwater Pollutant Removal Criteria (Chapter 4)

1.1 What the Manuals Require

Chapter 4 explains runoff-quality treatment and BMP selection. The older collection contains a February 2004 chapter, while the newer chapter is January 2026. The July 2023 rule already used regulated motor-vehicle surface; the earlier chapter's impervious-surface terminology must not be read as the July 2023 binding rule. July 2023 §5.5; January 2026 §5.5.

Earlier Chapter 4 (February 2004) - Core Requirements

January 2026 Chapter 4 - Core Requirements

1.2 Where Designers Typically Document Compliance

Under both editions, designers typically document Chapter 4 compliance in the stormwater management report through:

For 2026 work, it is also important to separate what is a Chapter 4 runoff-quality demonstration from what is a quantity or volumetric-reduction demonstration elsewhere in the corpus.

1.3 Notable Updates Between 2023 and 2026 Editions

Item February 2004 chapter January 2026 chapter
Main applicability trigger New or additional impervious surface Regulated motor vehicle surface and reconstruction of motor vehicle surface
Project examples Traditional runoff-quality examples Adds redevelopment / reconstruction examples and treatment-removal examples
Existing treatment removed Less explicit Explicit maintain-or-increase treatment logic when existing treatment is modified or removed
GI framing BMP selection can be structural or nonstructural GI BMPs required unless waiver or variance from N.J.A.C. 7:8-5.3
Nutrient guidance Typical nutrient-removal data supports BMP selection Same general role, updated table and rule framing

Chapter 4 should therefore remain a runoff-quality chapter in report writing and design review. Volumetric-reduction compliance is real in the 2026 framework, but it is grounded in the quantity standards at N.J.A.C. 7:8-5.6(d) and BMP Manual Chapter 14 rather than in Chapter 4 itself.


Section 2 - SWM Standards and Computations (Chapter 5)

2.1 What Standards Drive Sizing and Verification

Chapter 5 is the computation chapter. In both editions it explains how to calculate runoff rates, volumes, and hydrographs, and how to apply the quantity, quality, and recharge standards through accepted hydrologic and hydraulic methods.

In both editions, the chapter explains:

For quantity control, the key framework remains the current and projected 2-, 10-, and 100-year storm events. Include all three return periods in the chosen demonstration.

2.2 What Computations Are Commonly Referenced

At a conceptual level, the chapter commonly references:

The 2026 chapter is clearer and more explicit on the climate-adjusted rainfall side of the quantity analysis. It names current storm events and projected storm events, and ties them back to the rule tables for current precipitation adjustment factors and future precipitation change factors.

2.3 Notable Updates Between 2023 and 2026 Editions

Item 2023 2026
Quantity framework Current and projected 2-, 10-, and 100-year storm analysis already present Same storm set retained, with more explicit current / projected terminology
Rainfall inputs NOAA Atlas 14 plus rule-based adjustment factors already used in examples Same approach, but the current / projected framing is clearer and more front-loaded
Hydrograph compliance No exceedance allowed where hydrograph option is chosen Same rule concept retained
Example framing Detailed examples, including hydrographs and multi-point discharge analysis Adds clearer climate-adjusted and GI-oriented examples
Volumetric reduction guidance Not part of Chapter 5 Chapter 5 expressly says volumetric-reduction guidance is provided in Chapter 14, not here

Chapter 5 remains the computational hub for the current and projected storm analysis, but it is not itself the source of the Chapter 14 volumetric-reduction workflow. Where a 2026 engineering narrative addresses volumetric reduction, the governing support comes from N.J.A.C. 7:8-5.6(d) and Chapter 14.


Section 3 - Groundwater Recharge (Chapter 6)

3.1 Recharge Requirement Concepts and Applicability

Chapter 6 remains focused on the recharge standard itself and on the NJGRS-based methodology for meeting it.

Both editions support the same high-level structure:

3.2 What the Chapter Actually Emphasizes

The chapter's real emphasis is:

The chapter does not itself function as a detailed soil-investigation protocol chapter. It points to other material for that level of design and testing detail.

3.3 Notable Updates Between 2023 and 2026 Editions

Both supplied Chapter 6 documents are the July 2023 revision. Their NJGRS instructions and recharge-BMP input guidance are unchanged in this comparison.

The main takeaways are:

For practice-level detail, Chapter 12 provides the soil-testing requirements, Chapter 13 provides the groundwater-mounding inputs and design-rate treatment, and BMP-specific chapters in Chapters 9 and 10 provide many of the SHWT, underdrain, drain-time, and liner details that engineers use in final design.


Section 4 - Practical Design and Review Implications

4.1 What Changes in Design Workflow

The engineering workflow implications that emerge from Chapters 4 to 6 are straightforward:

  1. Runoff-quality review includes the January 2026 reconstruction provisions. The newer Chapter 4 trigger turns on regulated motor vehicle surface and reconstruction logic, so engineers must classify the project trigger carefully rather than defaulting to the older impervious-surface shorthand.
  2. Quantity analysis must address all three design storms. Chapters 5 and the companion rule text support current and projected 2-, 10-, and 100-year analysis, not a reduced storm set.
  3. Climate-adjusted rainfall handling is more explicit. The 2026 Chapter 5 presentation makes current and projected rainfall adjustments a more visible part of the quantity workflow.
  4. Recharge remains a two-path framework. Chapter 6 still centers Requirement 1 versus Requirement 2, with NJGRS-based annual recharge work remaining a core design path.

Where the workflow reaches beyond Chapters 4 to 6, the broader manual makes the connection clear: volumetric reduction is grounded in N.J.A.C. 7:8-5.6(d) and Chapter 14, and the detailed infiltration soil testing and groundwater-mounding analysis are developed in Chapters 12 and 13.

4.2 What Changes in Documentation Expected in a Submittal

Document Element Supportable 2023-2026 Reading
Runoff-quality narrative Must identify the correct Chapter 4 trigger and show the TSS / treatment-train basis used
Quantity analysis Must document the chosen quantity-control option and the current / projected 2-, 10-, and 100-year calculations or hydrographs
Recharge analysis Must document whether the design is meeting Requirement 1 or Requirement 2 and how the recharge demonstration is being computed
Climate-adjusted rainfall inputs More explicit in 2026 and should be shown clearly in model inputs and supporting tables
Volumetric reduction narrative If used, it should be identified as support from the broader 2026 corpus, especially N.J.A.C. 7:8-5.6(d) and Chapter 14
Soil testing / mounding backup If relied on, it should be sourced to Chapters 12 and 13 or BMP-specific chapters, not described as Chapter 6 text

4.3 Typical Reviewer Issues That Are Actually Supported

The following review themes remain central:

4.4 Engineering Implications

The chapter comparisons have three practical implications:

Where 2026 engineering practice truly does pull in volumetric reduction, detailed soil-testing rules, or groundwater-mounding conventions, those points are better sourced from the broader corpus and should be labeled that way.


End of Phase 1C Engineering Content Primary source scope for this report: NJ Stormwater BMP Manual Chapters 4-6, 2023 and 2026 editions. Limited fallback references above are explicitly identified as broader-corpus support.

Download this report as Markdown · Back to top